Angelina's Pizzeria

Angelina's Pizzeria, nestled in the vibrant heart of Key West, is quickly becoming a local favorite for pizza lovers. With a menu boasting classics like the Loaded Pizza—topped with pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese—alongside specialty options such as the Hawaiian and Meat Lovers, there’s something to satisfy every craving. For those preferring lighter fare, the Veggie Lovers Pizza showcases a medley of fresh vegetables, making every bite refreshing. Customer reviews speak highly of the inviting atmosphere and exceptional service. Many, like Jay Woodlee, returned daily for a slice, extolling the convenience and delight of grabbing a quick meal before hitting the lively local bars. The warm and friendly staff garner rave reviews, with one patron describing them as “genuinely kind” and attentive, enhancing the overall dining experience. While some diners noted preferences for crust texture, the praise for the flavor of the sauce and the quick service remains unanimous. With affordable prices—just $5 for a slice—and the thrill of dining amidst the bustling streets, Angelina’s embodies the quintessential Key West experience. Whether you stop in for a slice or opt for delivery after a sun-soaked day, this pizzeria promises not just great food, but a memorable encounter. For pizza enthusiasts seeking a fulfilling meal rich in flavor and warmth, Angelina's is an essential stop.